Two client emails, two different jobs
The introduction email goes to a hiring manager who has never heard of you. It stays under 100 words, gives one real reason for writing and asks for a 15-minute call.
The proposal email goes out only after you have spoken. In a few lines it confirms the role in the client's own words and gives the fee model in one sentence. It also says what is attached and sets the next step with a date.
A proposal sent to a stranger reads like an invoice nobody ordered.
My team books B2B meetings through cold email and LinkedIn. We are not a recruitment agency, so this guide has no recruitment case study. The advice comes from outbound work and from the official sources linked below.
My rule for any first message: ask for the meeting, sell nothing else. Pitching to someone who does not know you yet is the fastest way to get ignored. Targeting and volume belong to the wider cold email plan for recruitment agencies. Here I cover the emails and the short list check you need before writing them.
Which email do you send, and when?
Match the email to how much the client already knows about you.
| Where you stand | Goal | Length | The ask | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No contact yet | Cold introduction | Start a conversation | Under 100 words | A 15-minute call |
| Connected or chatted on LinkedIn | Warm introduction | Turn a familiar name into a call | Under 100 words | A call, with two time slots |
| They replied with interest | Scheduling reply | Lock in the call | 2 to 4 lines | Pick a slot |
| You had a discovery call | Proposal cover email | Put what you agreed in writing | About 150 words plus the PDF | A review call on a set date |
| They said yes on a call | Confirmation email | Get the terms signed | A few lines | Sign the terms and send the full brief |
Where you can, start in the LinkedIn row: the email then arrives from a name the hiring manager has already seen.
The scheduling reply and the confirmation email are a few lines each and need no template: restate the slot or the terms and attach the file. Nobody hires an agency from one email. They hire it after they check you out.
Gartner ran a survey in August and September 2025. It covered 646 B2B buyers. Two thirds of them wanted to buy without talking to a sales rep. The exact figure is 67% (Gartner).
So expect the hiring manager to open your LinkedIn profile and your website before replying. That check is also why the same email gets very different reply rates from two senders. I have seen it in our campaigns. One company got 2% replies. Another got 7.5% with the identical message.
Decision rule: your profile should say which roles you fill and for which industry, with at least one real result. If it does not, fix that first. Then send.
Who should a recruitment agency email at the hiring company?
Email the person who decides on hires in your niche, at a company that looks like your best past clients.
My lists start with the sender's best past clients. From there I search for lookalikes of those clients. For a recruitment agency, take the 10 clients who paid you the most or came back for a second role. Note each one's industry, headcount and location, plus the roles you filled. That profile becomes your list.
Next, I go back through past projects and ask who really made the decision. In recruitment it is often the hiring manager, not HR. For developer roles that is usually a head of engineering. For site or plant roles it is an operations director, and for accounting hires a finance director.
I search with the titles that niche actually uses. I strip titles such as Assistant, Associate and a bare "Manager" from my lists completely. No wording rescues a list built on the wrong people.
Run this check before you write a word:
- Every company resembles one of your best past clients.
- Every contact holds a title that has signed off hires in that niche.
- Every contact is a named person. Shared inboxes like jobs@ or hr@ stay off the list.
- Every address passes verification before the first send.
- Each contact is tagged with the past client it resembles. That tag is your reason to write.
Recruitment introduction email templates you can copy
Each template below:
- Stays under 100 words.
- Makes one ask.
- Has one result line you fill with a real placement, in your own words.
Never send the placeholder as it stands. If you have no relevant placement yet, drop the result line and lead with the market observation.
Write the opening line of each email by hand.
Gong's 2024 benchmarks come from its own customers' account executives and SDRs, so treat them as vendor data. They put the median cold email reply rate at 1.8%: 2.1% for manual emails and 1.1% for automated ones (Gong).
Template 1: cold email to a hiring manager
Subject: [Role] hiring in [city]
Hi [First name],
I noticed the [role] ad at [company] has been open since [month]. Last quarter we [one real result: what you filled, for what kind of company, how fast].
I am not attaching CVs or a rate card. Could we take 15 minutes? I would like to understand what the role really needs, and I can tell you what candidates in [city] are asking for.
Does [day] at [time] work?
[Name], [Agency], [postal address] If this is not relevant, reply "stop" and I will not write again.
"Not attaching CVs" removes the fear of a hard sell. You are selling the meeting, nothing else. A free call is not free for them, so the email has to sell the 15 minutes. The signature covers the postal address and the opt-out. Check the legal table below for the rest, including the US rule that the email must be clearly identifiable as an ad. Take your first line from the company's own news, not from a merge field.
Template 2: after a LinkedIn connection
Subject: [Company]'s new [team or site] in [place]
Hi [First name],
Thanks for accepting my connection last week. I saw [company] is opening [team or site] in [place], which usually means [role type] hires within a few months.
We recruit [role type] for [industry] firms in [region]. [One real result.]
Worth 15 minutes to compare notes on how hard those roles are to fill right now? [Day] or [day]?
[Signature with postal address and opt-out line]
The subject names their news, and the first line reminds them where they saw you. Two slots let them choose without having to write a long reply.
Template 3: referral or past placement
Subject: [Referrer] suggested I write
Hi [First name],
[Referrer] hired a [role] through us at [their company] and mentioned you are growing [team]. The hire is still there [number] months on, and [Referrer] is happy to tell you how the search went.
Before I suggest anyone, I would like to understand the brief. Could we take 15 minutes on [day]?
[Signature with postal address and opt-out line]
More honest subject lines to test: "Question about your [role] search", "[Company] and the [team] expansion" and "[Role type] candidates in [region] this quarter". More worked examples come from cold emails rewritten line by line.
How do you write the proposal cover email after the call?
Send it while the call is still fresh, ideally the same or the next working day.
Subject: Proposal for your [role] search
Hi [First name],
Thanks for [day]'s call. To confirm what you told me: you need a [role] who can [their words], based in [location], starting by [date]. The last search stalled because [their reason].
The proposal is attached. It runs to two pages and covers the process, the timeline and the terms.
Fee in one line: [the fee sentence from the next section].
Next step: a 20-minute review with [second decision maker] on [date]. Does [time] suit you both?
[Signature]
| Item | In the email body | In the PDF or link |
|---|---|---|
| The role | 2 to 3 lines in the client's own words | The full brief: must-haves, salary band, location, start date |
| Fee | One sentence | Full terms, payment schedule, replacement terms |
| Process | One line | Each stage with dates: search, shortlist, interviews, offer |
| Proof | Nothing extra, because the intro already did that job | One short case and references |
| Next step | A date and a time | Repeated on the last page |
| Legal terms | None | Terms of business, ready to sign |
Gmail says a subject line may only begin with Re: or Fwd: when the message truly is a reply or a forward (Google).
If you booked the call in an email thread, the proposal can honestly go as a reply in that thread. Name the file so it makes sense when forwarded, for example [Agency]-[Company]-[Role]-proposal.pdf.
How do you word contingency, retained and hybrid fees in an email?
Each model fits in one sentence:
- Contingency: you are paid only when a candidate you introduced starts.
- Retained: the client pays part of the fee up front for a committed search.
- Hybrid: a small commitment fee at the start, plus a completion fee when the hire starts.
Paste-ready sentences follow. Fill the brackets with your own terms. For a rough anchor, Pin, a recruiting software vendor, says standard contingency fees run 15-25% of the hire's first-year salary. It cites SHRM for 20-25% of first-year cash compensation.
Pin puts retained search at 25% to 35% of total first-year compensation, base plus bonuses, with minimum engagement fees often starting at $80,000-$100,000. Ranges vary with role seniority, scarcity and exclusivity. I have no sourced figure for hybrid fees. Yours depend on your niche and your contracts.
- Contingency: "Our fee is [X%] of the first-year base salary, invoiced when the candidate starts. If you do not hire through us, you pay nothing."
- Retained: "This is a retained search. [X%] of the fee is due at the start, [X%] when we present the shortlist by [date], and the balance when the candidate starts."
- Hybrid: "We charge a commitment fee of [amount] at the start, credited against a completion fee of [X%] of first-year base salary when the hire starts."
- Replacement terms: "If the hire leaves within [period], we [replace them at no extra fee / refund X%], as set out in the attached terms."
Rebates, exclusivity and invoicing go in the terms. State the model even if the client never asked about fees on the call. A fee that first shows up in the PDF looks like something you hid.
How many times should you follow up, and with what?
Most people polish the first email and never send a second. Skip the follow-ups and you lose a big share of replies. Instantly's 2026 cold email benchmark is vendor data from its own platform. It found the first email captures 58% of replies. Follow-ups capture the other 42%.
In our campaigns, follow-up number 3 is usually the one that gets the reply. So plan the intro as a sequence from day one. Mix LinkedIn and email. Aim for 5 to 6 touches. Leave real time between them.
| Touch | Channel | Its job |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | LinkedIn connection request, no pitch | Your name appears before your email does |
| 2 | Intro email (template 1 or 2) | The 15-minute ask with one result |
| 3 | Email, follow-up 1 | A new angle: the hiring problem this role usually brings |
| 4 | LinkedIn message, follow-up 2 | One short question about their hiring plans |
| 5 | Email, follow-up 3 | Fresh proof: a second placement or a note on candidate supply in their city |
| 6 | Email, follow-up 4 | A clean close: ask whether to stop writing |
"Just checking in" adds nothing and tells the hiring manager you are out of ideas.
The proposal sequence is shorter, because they already know you. Three touches, each adding something new:
| Touch | What it adds |
|---|---|
| 1 | The answer to a question left open on the call, or one the second decision maker will ask |
| 2 | A market note, such as how many people in [city] match the brief, or the shortlist date if you start this week |
| 3 | A close: should you hold the start date, or close the file? |
If anyone says no or asks you to stop, the sequence ends there.
What does the law require in a B2B recruitment email?
Use this table as your B2B legal minimum for the UK and the US. PECR is the UK's Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations, and CAN-SPAM is the US federal law on commercial email.
| Requirement | UK (PECR and UK GDPR) | US (CAN-SPAM) |
|---|---|---|
| Consent before the first email | Not needed for limited companies and other corporate subscribers. Consent or a soft opt-in (an existing customer relationship plus a chance to refuse) is needed for sole traders and some partnerships | No consent step, yet all the rules below still cover B2B email |
| Who you are | Never hide or disguise your identity | Header information must be accurate |
| Subject and content | - | The subject must not mislead, and the email must make clear it is an ad |
| Opt-out | A valid address to opt out in every email | A working opt-out for at least 30 days after sending, honored within 10 business days |
| Postal address | - | A valid physical postal address in every email |
| Named contacts | UK GDPR applies to addresses like initials.lastname@company.com. Privacy information is due within one month if the data came from elsewhere. An objection to marketing is absolute | - |
| Penalty | Fines up to £500,000, and directors can be liable | Up to $53,088 per violating email |
UK. The UK rows come from the ICO's guidance on B2B marketing. Its own example is a recruitment firm: when an HR director at a limited company asks it to stop, it stops and adds them to a do-not-contact list. The fine level and director liability are on the ICO's overview of PECR.
US. For the US rows I used the FTC's CAN-SPAM compliance guide. It covers single emails as well as bulk sends, and if someone sends on your behalf, both of you can be liable.
The ICO flags its B2B guidance as open to change while it reworks them under the Data (Use and Access) Act, so recheck the UK rows, ideally with a lawyer, before a big send.
Europe. For hiring companies in Germany, Austria or the Czech Republic, my agency sends no cold email unless a compliant basis exists; LinkedIn is the route there.
Your first week: list check, profile, then the 15-minute ask
- Run the five-point list check.
- Fix your LinkedIn profile so it names the roles and industry you work in, with one real result.
- Send template 1 or 2.
- Plan touches 3 to 6, and have your proposal cover email and fee sentence ready before the first call.
The same logic works outside recruitment in how to write a sales introduction email.
Writing your first email to a hiring manager? Book a call, bring the draft, and I will tell you which line I would cut and what ask I would make instead.
Questions recruiters ask about client emails
Should you mention the client's current recruitment agency?
No, and never criticize it. Ask which roles have been hardest to fill this year. A company that already has a supplier may still bring in a specialist for one difficult search. If they name their agency, listen for the gap: speed, shortlist quality or reach in a niche. Position yourself for that single role.
Can a recruiter send a proposal to a client who has not asked for one?
Avoid it. Without the call you cannot price the real brief, because salary band, location and urgency all change the terms. There is one exception. If the client replies to your intro and asks about fees, answer in a single sentence. Then propose the call where you can price the actual role.
Should the proposal email go to HR or to the hiring manager when both were on the call?
Address it to the person who signs the terms, and copy the other. Write the role recap for the hiring manager, because they own the outcome. Keep the fee sentence and the terms where HR or procurement will look for them. Use one thread for both, so nobody forwards an older version.
What if the hiring manager forwards your intro email to HR?
Treat it as a warm lead. Reply to HR in the same thread, mention who passed it on and ask the same 15-minute question. Keep the hiring manager copied, because their needs shape the brief.
